Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

🏡 West Windsor Real Estate Revealed: What Actually Sold (and What Didn’t)

Real estate John A. Terebey April 16, 2025

🔥 West Windsor Real Estate: The 6-Month Reality Check You’ve Been Waiting For
By John Terebey | Terebey Relocation Team

From October 2024 through April 2025, 114 homes were listed across West Windsor and Princeton. But here’s the kicker: only 66.7% sold. That’s a 1 in 3 failure rate — and most of those misses come down to one thing: pricing.

Let’s break it down — what’s working, what’s not, and which brokerages are actually delivering.


🏆 What’s Selling: Where Buyers Are Biting

  • 4-bedroom detached homes: These are king right now. 84.6% sold successfully — that’s as close to a slam dunk as it gets.

  • $1M–$1.5M price point: 83.3% success rate. It’s the market’s sweet spot.

  • Condos and end-unit townhomes: Underrated, but when priced right, they’re moving.


🚫 What’s Not Selling (And Why)

  • Anything over $2M: Not a single sale closed in this bracket. Zero for four. That’s a red flag.

  • Interior townhouses: Only a 50% success rate. Buyers want space and privacy — and they're not compromising.

  • Luxury 5-6 bedroom homes: More house doesn’t always mean more demand. These had success rates under 50%.


💰 The 16.7% “Reality Gap” That’s Crushing Sellers

On average, expired listings were priced 20% higher than the ones that sold. Translation: sellers who ignored the market paid the price. Today’s buyers are smart — and they’re not overpaying.

To win, you need to price it right from the start. Period.


🏢 Brokerage Spotlight: Who’s Getting It Done

Let’s talk brokerage performance — because it matters.

💼 BHHS Fox & Roach – Princeton

With 15 listings and a 73.3% success rate, BHHS led the market in both volume and total sales.
Their average closed price was $761,818, and they moved more properties than any other office. That speaks to deep market knowledge and execution — not just promises.

Yes, some expired listings skewed high in price, but it’s also a signal that BHHS is trusted with both high-end and high-volume listings — a position few can claim.

Other Top Performers:

  • Keller Williams Real Estate – Princeton: 100% success rate (6 listings)

  • Century 21 Abrams & Associates: Highest avg transaction value ($1.135M) with 100% success

  • Keller Williams Premier: Strong presence in the luxury space with a $1.22M average sale

What’s clear? The right brokerage makes a measurable difference.


🔍 The Terebey Takeaway: What This Means for You

If you’re thinking about selling in West Windsor, here’s how to position yourself to win:

  • Don’t chase the price ceiling — respect it

  • Focus on what buyers actually want: 4 beds, private layout, well-priced

  • Choose a team that reads the market in real time, not just lists and waits

At the Terebey Relocation Team, we don’t guess — we strategize. We analyze buyer behavior, align pricing for velocity, and position your home to dominate its segment.

We understand that volume without precision is just noise. That’s why we blend high-level marketing with hard data — and why we continue to lead Mercer County.


Ready to Sell Smarter?

Let’s have a conversation. We’ll walk you through the numbers, the trends, and the custom strategy to maximize your property’s impact.

📞 Schedule a Strategy Call
📍 Based in Mercer County | Trusted Across New Jersey
🚀 Powered by Data. Driven by Results. Led by Vision.

Recent Blog Posts

Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.

Buyers

First time home-buyers: Unlock your Dream with Neighbor First Program

First-Time Buyer? Say Goodbye to PMI, High Rates, and Big Down Payments with This Powerful Homeownership Program

Mortgages

Loans, Limits & Life Hacks: Your NJ & PA Mortgage Survival Guide (That Most Buyers Never Read)

our No-Fluff Guide to Beating the Mortgage System and Winning in a Competitive Market

Investment

Real Estate Investment Opportunities in Mercer County, NJ

How Ewing and Princeton Offer Two Distinct — Yet Powerful — Paths to Real Estate Wealth in Central New Jersey

Buyer

Surf, Sand, and Sold Signs: Why Manahawkin, Beach Haven, and LBI Are On Fire in 2025

Discover what’s behind the red-hot demand in these Jersey Shore markets—where home values are rising, listings are vanishing, and buyers are racing to the water’s edge.

Buyers

The Value of Using a Buyer’s Agent in Today’s Real Estate Market

Discover how a buyer’s agent can give you exclusive access, protect your interests, and secure better deals in today’s competitive real estate market.

Buying

Plainsboro Real Estate Market Update: April 2025 Trends & Insights

Explore April’s key housing trends in Plainsboro—discover where sellers hold the advantage, where buyers can negotiate, and what to expect heading into mid-2025.

insurance

Cracks in the Foundation: The Homeowners Insurance Crisis in New Jersey and Across America

What Every Home Buyer and Seller Needs to Know About Rising Insurance Costs and Shrinking Coverage

mortgages

🏠 Credit Scores & Home Buying: What Every Future Homeowner Needs to Know

A Practical Guide to How Your Credit Score Impacts Your Mortgage — And What You Can Do About It

Buying

The West Windsor Housing Market

What Buyers and Sellers Need to Know in 2025

Work With Us

Etiam non quam lacus suspendisse faucibus interdum. Orci ac auctor augue mauris augue neque. Bibendum at varius vel pharetra. Viverra orci sagittis eu volutpat.